Documentary Storytelling

Copyright Basics for History Pages on Facebook: Five Myths and a Safer Workflow

A plain-language guide for people who run history pages in the US, UK and Canada: four ways to use a work legally, five common myths (credit, non-commercial, 'under 30 seconds'), and a safer routine. Not legal advice.

By Rajib Roy Published 5 min read

A history page can be taken down, or lose a post to a copyright claim, with one reused photograph. The usual reaction is disbelief: "But I credited them." "It's educational." "It's only ten seconds." Those are the myths that cause trouble, and they come from a half-understanding of how copyright works.

This post is a plain-language guide for people who run history and documentary pages for readers in the US, the UK and Canada. It covers four legitimate ways to use a work, five myths, and a routine that keeps you out of most trouble. This post is general information, not legal advice. Copyright law differs by country and by the facts of each case, and I am not a lawyer. For anything high-stakes, ask a qualified copyright lawyer.

The basic idea

Copyright gives the creator of an original work, such as a photograph, a film, a piece of music or a text, the right to control copying and sharing, for a limited time. When you post someone else's work you are copying and sharing it, so you need a reason you're allowed. There are four legitimate reasons, and the first three are far safer than the fourth.

Four ways to use a work

  1. You made it

    Your own photographs, footage, maps and writing. Keep the originals and a note of the date.

  2. It is in the public domain

    The copyright has expired or never existed. In the US, works of the federal government are not eligible for copyright under section 105 of the Copyright Act, and works published in 1930 or earlier are now generally free of US copyright, according to Duke's Public Domain Day page, which also stresses that it covers US law only. The UK has its own durations: the National Archives says a published Crown copyright work is protected for 50 years from the end of the year of publication. The post on archival footage goes into the traps.

  3. You have a licence or permission

    An open licence that you follow, or written permission from the rights holder. Keep the proof.

  4. An exception applies

    In the US this is fair use; in Canada, fair dealing; the UK has its own exceptions. They are real, but they're judged case by case, which is why they are the riskiest basis.

What the exceptions actually say

The US Copyright Office explains that fair use is a legal doctrine that allows unlicensed use in certain circumstances. Section 107 lists purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship and research, and sets four factors: the purpose and character of the use (including whether it is commercial or nonprofit educational, and whether it is transformative); the nature of the work; the amount and substantiality of what is used; and the effect on the market for the original. It says courts decide each case on its facts and that there is no formula guaranteeing that a set percentage, or a number of words, lines or pages, can be used without permission. The Office also says it cannot give legal advice to individual members of the public.

Canada's approach is different in its wording. Section 29.1 of the Copyright Act says that fair dealing for the purpose of criticism or review does not infringe copyright if the source, and where it's given the author, performer, maker or broadcaster, are mentioned. It has separate provisions for other purposes such as research, education and news reporting. I haven't researched the UK's fair dealing rules for this post, so don't assume they match either.

The key point for a page with readers in several countries is that an exception in one place does not carry over to the others.

Five myths

  1. "I credited the source, so it's fine." Credit tells people where something came from. It isn't permission. The Canadian rule above does require a mention for criticism or review, but only as one condition of a use that must also be fair.
  2. "It's non-commercial, or it's educational." The US Copyright Office says courts are more likely to find noncommercial educational uses fair, but also says that doesn't mean all of them are. It is one factor of four.
  3. "It's under thirty seconds, or ten percent." The Office states plainly that there is no formula giving a safe percentage or number of words, lines, pages or copies. Short isn't automatically safe.
  4. "It's on the internet, so anyone can use it." Being easy to copy has nothing to do with being allowed to copy.
  5. "It's old, so it's free." Old can mean public domain, but the dates vary by country and by whether a work was published. And a new photograph of an old painting or a new recording of an old song can carry its own rights.

A sixth belief is worth a mention: "The archive has it, so it's free." The National Archives' own page says that not all of its records are public domain and that it does not confirm copyright status. The archive is where you read the rights statement, not the end of the question.

A safer routine

  1. Prefer your own and public-domain material

    Build each post around what you can document: your photographs, government works, items old enough to be free in the country you rely on.

  2. Keep a rights log

    One row per item: source address, rights basis, credit line, date checked. The archival footage post has a checker for this.

  3. Ask when you're unsure

    Rights holders often say yes to a small page that credits them. Keep the reply.

  4. Treat fair use and fair dealing as a last resort

    If your only reason is "I think it's fair", consider a different image. If you do rely on it, write down your reasoning.

  5. Check the whole item

    Music, narration, a third-party logo or a person's likeness can each carry separate rights.

A permission request template

Here is wording you can adapt. It's my own draft and hasn't been reviewed by a lawyer:

Subject: Permission request: [item title], [your page name]

Hello,

I run [page name], a history page about [topic] with readers in the US, UK and Canada.
I'd like to use [item, with its catalogue number or link] in a [post/video] about [subject].
It would be shown for about [N] seconds with the credit "[credit line you'd use]".

Could you tell me whether this is possible, and on what terms (fee, credit wording, any limits)?
I will not use it until I hear back.

Thank you,
[name]

If you get a claim

Read the notice carefully, remove the item if you can't show your right to use it, and don't ignore it. How platforms handle notices and disputes is outside what I've researched here, so read the platform's current policy, and if the stakes are high, talk to a lawyer.

What I haven't verified

  • UK exceptions, and the rules of countries beyond the US, UK and Canada.
  • Any platform's takedown or counter-notice process.
  • That the template wording suits your situation.
  • Any of this with a lawyer.

This post is general information, not legal advice. Copyright law differs by country and by the facts of each case, and I am not a lawyer. For anything high-stakes, ask a qualified copyright lawyer.

What I ran this against

  • Nothing in this post was run or tested as code. It is a summary of public legal and government sources, read on 17 November 2026. No lawyer has reviewed it, and I did not check any platform's policies or enforcement. This post is general information, not legal advice. Copyright law differs by country and by the facts of each case, and I am not a lawyer. For anything high-stakes, ask a qualified copyright lawyer.
  • The sample permission-request wording is a template I wrote. It has not been checked by a lawyer and nobody has sent it.

Sources checked

  • U.S. Copyright Office, "Fair Use Index" and its About Fair Use text (section 107, four factors, case-by-case, no formula for a percentage or number of words or seconds; it cannot give legal advice to the public): copyright.gov/fair-use, read 17 November 2026.
  • Copyright Act (Canada), section 29.1 "Criticism or review" (fair dealing for criticism or review does not infringe if the source and, where given, the author, performer, maker or broadcaster are mentioned): laws-lois.justice.gc.ca, read 17 November 2026.
  • 17 U.S. Code § 105, "Subject matter of copyright: United States Government works" (copyright protection is not available for any work of the United States Government; the section also has narrow provisions for certain Defense-related faculty works): law.cornell.edu, read 17 November 2026.
  • Duke Center for the Study of the Public Domain, "Public Domain Day 2026" (on 1 January 2026, works published in 1930, and sound recordings from 1925, entered the US public domain; the site is about US law only and other countries' terms differ): web.law.duke.edu, read 17 November 2026.
  • The National Archives (UK), "Crown copyright FAQs" (published Crown copyright works are protected for 50 years from the end of the year of publication; unpublished works for 125 years from the end of the year they were made or until 31 December 2039; Crown copyright material should generally be available for re-use under the Open Government Licence): nationalarchives.gov.uk, read 17 November 2026.
  • National Archives (NARA), "Permissions / Rights for Use of Special Media Records at NARA" (works of US federal agencies and employees are not eligible for US copyright and are treated as public domain, but not all NARA holdings are; NARA does not confirm copyright status or license its content; the user is responsible; suggested audiovisual credit "Courtesy: National Archives and Records Administration"; page last reviewed 25 April 2023): archives.gov, read 17 November 2026.